International Leaks from Biden admin shows they do deserve full blame for Afghanistan

cottagecheesefan

Steel Belt
@Steel
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
30,221
Reaction score
28,254
I know posters, including a few on the right have said they don't believe Biden deserves all the blame/credit for the terrible Afghan withdrawal, and that it was bound to happen. However, others argue that the chaos and quick evacuation that lead to the attack was due to the administration.

Keep in mind the time line too. Taliban officially officially took Kabul on 8/15 and the airport bombing was 8/26. According to the leak, 8/14 was the first Biden admin joint meeting about evacuating people, despite receiving many warnings from many people as early as February.

Axios (a liberal source, not Fox, Project Veritas, etc) reporting on documents they obtained.


https://www.axios.com/leaked-docume...res-c27d790c-3a50-4734-8543-7db710898bb2.html




Some highlights. The admin did NOT have a meeting on relocating people until 8/14, the day the Taliban reached Kabul:

  • The document regarded "Relocations out of Afghanistan," and the meeting was held from 3:30-4:30pm on the afternoon of Aug. 14, Washington time.
  • At that moment, Taliban fighters were descending upon Kabul.
  • The meeting was chaired by National Security Council official Liz Sherwood-Randall and included senior officials across multiple agencies, including Gen. John Hyten, vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

Many outside advisers were sounding the alarm as the Taliban swept through provincial capitals heading into August. Here they have a CIA operative saying they had been in contact with the admin since February.

  • "I kept being told by people in the [White House] the thing they were most concerned about was the optics of a chaotic evacuation," said Matt Zeller, a former CIA officer who contacted administration officials in February 2021 about protecting Afghans who worked with the Americans. "They treated us like we were Chicken Little. They didn’t believe the sky was falling."
  • "On the 13th of July, we offered to work with them to help evacuate our partners," Zeller added. "We all saw this disaster coming before the inevitable occurred. They didn’t get back to us until Aug 15, the day Kabul fell."
Mark Jacobson, deputy NATO representative in Afghanistan during the Obama administration, told Axios: "That so much planning, prioritizing and addressing of key questions had not been completed, even as Kabul was about to fall, underscores the absence of adequate interagency planning."
 
I know posters, including a few on the right have said they don't believe Biden deserves all the blame/credit for the terrible Afghan withdrawal, and that it was bound to happen. However, others argue that the chaos and quick evacuation that lead to the attack was due to the administration.

Keep in mind the time line too. Taliban officially officially took Kabul on 8/15 and the airport bombing was 8/26. According to the leak, 8/14 was the first Biden admin joint meeting about evacuating people, despite receiving many warnings from many people as early as February.

Axios (a liberal source, not Fox, Project Veritas, etc) reporting on documents they obtained.


https://www.axios.com/leaked-docume...res-c27d790c-3a50-4734-8543-7db710898bb2.html




Some highlights. The admin did NOT have a meeting on relocating people until 8/14, the day the Taliban reached Kabul:

  • The document regarded "Relocations out of Afghanistan," and the meeting was held from 3:30-4:30pm on the afternoon of Aug. 14, Washington time.
  • At that moment, Taliban fighters were descending upon Kabul.
  • The meeting was chaired by National Security Council official Liz Sherwood-Randall and included senior officials across multiple agencies, including Gen. John Hyten, vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

Many outside advisers were sounding the alarm as the Taliban swept through provincial capitals heading into August. Here they have a CIA operative saying they had been in contact with the admin since February.

  • "I kept being told by people in the [White House] the thing they were most concerned about was the optics of a chaotic evacuation," said Matt Zeller, a former CIA officer who contacted administration officials in February 2021 about protecting Afghans who worked with the Americans. "They treated us like we were Chicken Little. They didn’t believe the sky was falling."
  • "On the 13th of July, we offered to work with them to help evacuate our partners," Zeller added. "We all saw this disaster coming before the inevitable occurred. They didn’t get back to us until Aug 15, the day Kabul fell."
Mark Jacobson, deputy NATO representative in Afghanistan during the Obama administration, told Axios: "That so much planning, prioritizing and addressing of key questions had not been completed, even as Kabul was about to fall, underscores the absence of adequate interagency planning."

No one is shocked including the ones that support this Muppet.
 
I initially defended Biden, as that was never going to be a clean and easy evacuation from that shithole. But I'd be interested to see where this story goes and how much advanced knowledge they had. Don't expect anything from it though. The media will ignore it much like they shrugged off the 12 marines dying, the Afghans falling off an evacuating military plane, and $60 billion worth of military weapons and transportation forfeited to the enemy. There will be no commission to investigate it. It'll just go away.
 
"The president himself — and his intelligence community — overestimated the ability of the Afghan military to defend their territory against the Taliban."

anybody with two neurons understood what was going on.
the chinese were already meeting with the taliban from february, russians were also on the ground, establishing relations in a post-america afghanistan.
but the "intelligence community" in america had no clue. that's what happens when half your budget goes to spying on your on population.
i still remember some screeching loons in this very forum yelling how NOBODY COULD HAVE PREDICTED. fuck you, you absolute morons, you know who you are.
 
Easily the best thing he's done so far is getting out of Afghanistan. Don't really care that much about the process.

While I agree that getting out of there was of paramount importance, you don't care about the process? If there was prior intel that could have potentially helped avoid the deaths of those 12 Marines and it was given to the Biden admin and ignored, wouldn't that outrage you?
 
While I agree that getting out of there was of paramount importance, you don't care about the process? If there was prior intel that could have potentially helped avoid the deaths of those 12 Marines and it was given to the Biden admin and ignored, wouldn't that outrage you?

How could the administration have prevented the military deaths of the Marines exactly? They died from a suicide bomber which is an extremely common occurrence (unfortunately) in the Middle East.
 
While I agree that getting out of there was of paramount importance, you don't care about the process? If there was prior intel that could have potentially helped avoid the deaths of those 12 Marines and it was given to the Biden admin and ignored, wouldn't that outrage you?

what is worse though, it that you didn't need intel at a certain point either. It was clear in July what was happening. Early July is when sizable territory first started being taken almost daily. For them to have had their meeting the day the Taliban reached Kabul (the day before Kabul was considered in Taliban control) is total incompetence. That isn't on Miley or Austin, that is on the Admin for having this joint meeting so late to determine their evacuation plans.

This leak isn't including the destruction or removal of military equipment, among other problems with the withdrawal.
 
Qatar did a lot of the heavy lifting in regards to evacuation.

Now, they are designated as a "Major non-NATO Ally".

Interesting how that worked out for them.

What kind of special goodies will Doha now get from the beltway?
 
I initially defended Biden, as that was never going to be a clean and easy evacuation from that shithole. But I'd be interested to see where this story goes and how much advanced knowledge they had. Don't expect anything from it though. The media will ignore it much like they shrugged off the 12 marines dying, the Afghans falling off an evacuating military plane, and $60 billion worth of military weapons and transportation forfeited to the enemy. There will be no commission to investigate it. It'll just go away.

This shit is so dumb and you guys do this all the time.

The thing that they reported and you only heard about because they reported it, was somehow ignored.
 
Honestly could care less. I'm just glad we are out of that fucking place.

You don't give a shit about the 13 murdered service members or the hundreds of others that were maimed during the pull out?

This is Nicole Gee. She lived in Roseville, California (my hometown). She went to my high school, Oakmont. Like me, she is a Viking. She was blown up at the airport.

sgt%20gee.jpg


I've been wanting us out of there for years. But there is a right way and a wrong way and Biden, the Sec State, Joint Chief's Boss all got this incredibly wrong and people like Nicole paid the ultimate price.
 
Last edited:
How could the administration have prevented the military deaths of the Marines exactly? They died from a suicide bomber which is an extremely common occurrence (unfortunately) in the Middle East.

You didn't answer my question. But to answer yours, I don't know. Suicide bombers are difficult to detect sometimes but, as you said, they are common in the Middle East. Common enough so that, if you are planning an evacuation there should be checkpoints along the way to make sure nobody with explosive devices on them got anywhere near where those Marines were. How could you not care about the process if there was potentially info ignored that could have saved them?
 
Back
Top